Warnings By Poles of Shoah IGNORED Karski

Story of a Secret State: My Report to the World, by Jan Karski, Madeleine K. Albright (Foreword), Zbigniew Brzeziński (Afterword), Timothy Snyder (Goodreads Author) (Contributor). 2013

Karski’s Historic Trip: A Polish Underground Operation (Not the Deeds of a Lone Idealist). Roosevelt Lied to Polish Leaders

Jan Karski’s trip to England and the US, which warned the Allies of the Holocaust in progress, is well known. However, Karski is often incorrectly thought of as some sort of unusual moral giant who tried to save the Jews all on his own. In fact, as this book makes clear, his heroic trip was planned, ordered, and performed in the context of his active, multifaceted involvement in the Polish Underground. For example, Karski’s visit to the Belzec death camp [or nearby subcamp] was facilitated by a rendezvous on the nearby property of a Polish farmer who was also a member of the Underground (p. 340).

1939 GERMAN 5th COLUMN

Karski was involved in the defense of Poland from the first hours of WWII. A few authors (e. g. Alfred-Maurice de Zayas) have tried to deny the existence of a German fifth column during the German-Soviet conquest of Poland (September-October 1939). In actuality, Karski’s very unit came under fire from members of this fifth column (p. 8). The attackers were Polish citizens of German descent.

IN THE CLUTCHES OF THE NAZIS AND SOVIETS

Karski ended up in Soviet and then German captivity. He repeatedly writes of the unbelievable barbarity of both conquerors. While in a Gestapo prison, Karski slashed his wrists in an unsuccessful suicide attempt. He had feared that he might break down under the incessant torture and betray his confidants in the Polish Underground. Karski was freed by a daring commando attack by the Underground combined with a well-placed bribe of a German guard.

CULTURAL GENOCIDE

Karski elaborates on the forced Germanization of Poznan (pp. 78-82), something attempted unsuccessfully before under Frederick the Great and then Bismarck. The Poles were brutally expelled. Very few of the remaining Poles chose to register as Germans and thus become Volksdeutsche.

GERMANS TRIED, BUT COULD NOT FIND, A SUITABLE POLISH QUISLING

Karski (p. 132) succinctly summarizes the attitude of almost all full-blooded Poles to the Nazis: “The German occupation was never recognized by the Polish people, and there could be no doubt on this score because, in Poland alone of all the occupied countries, there never appeared anything resembling a legal or pseudo-legal body composed of Poles and collaborating with the Germans. Indeed, in all of Poland, not a single political office in the German-controlled administration was ever held by a Pole; not a single head of any province was Polish”.

Neo-Stalinist Jan T. Gross has insinuated that Poles had no Quisling because the Germans did not want any Polish Quisling. Jan Karski’s personal experience with the Germans adds to the refutation to Gross’ silly claim. While a captive of the dreaded Gestapo, Karski was personally approached by a high-ranking SS man (pp. 155-163) who tried to induce him to become a Polish Quisling. The SS-man promised him relief from torture, and then appealed to the hopelessness of the Polish cause and the certainty of German victory in the wake of the fall of France and the seemingly-incipient peace treaty with England. The SS-man also cited the sensibleness of all the other nations that had formed collaborationist governments under German rule and said that Poles should also, for once, come to their senses and do the same. Karski refused.

SO-CALLED GERMAN RESISTANCE TO NAZISM

Karski visited Nazi Germany itself. He reports (p. 217) never encountering any sign of German opposition to the Nazi rule. (Of course, some developed later as Germany began to lose one battle after another, and the attempt was made to assassinate Hitler in order to save Germany’s skin from increasingly certain defeat).

PRESIDENT ROOSEVELT LIED TO THE POLES

A certain amount of detail is given to Karski’s visits with British and American leaders. It is a shame that Roosevelt made such supportive statements about Poland while, behind Karski’s back, he was already selling out the Poles to the Soviet Union.

A REFLECTION

Here we are nearly 75 years after WWII, and what has happened? Instead of being grateful for Karski’s efforts, far too many Jews defame Poland about her alleged complicity in the Holocaust [whatever that means].

For shame.